From the AAHPM 2005 Annual Meeting: ÒChanging Lenses: Using Popular Film to Enhance Medical Education on Communication, Empathy and Self-ReflectionÓ
Daniel Johnson, MD, Life Quality Institute, Denver, Colorado
|
Film Title |
Theme(s) |
Other Comments |
|
299 Days in the Life
of Nora Lenihan |
Hospice Care |
|
|
A Family Undertaking |
Normalizes dying |
Family provide at home funerals |
|
A Time to Kill |
Empathy; loss of imaginative capacity |
Final closing remarks of defense attorney |
|
Bambi |
Traumatic death |
|
|
Scene after mother is shot |
Healing after grief, surrounded by pals (except
thumper!!) |
|
|
Barbarian Invasions |
Divided family coming together at end of life.
Euthanasia |
At the end of the film, death is hastened with I.V.
heroin |
|
Pt who learns he is dying, family and friends rally
around him, he is able to die at home with their help |
|
|
|
Beaches |
Dying at home verses hospital, grief, childhood
grief |
Use to show peaceful death |
|
Big Chill |
Grief scene in shower |
Letting go |
|
Big Fish |
"Death Narratives" |
|
|
Bill MoyerÕs
ÒHealing and the MindÓ |
Bill Moyer's film series |
Use example with Jon Kabat-Zinn group therapy to
see how mindfulness can change a patient's life |
|
Bill MoyerÕs ÒOn Our
Own TermsÓ (PBS) |
Clips on death/dying. ALS clip discussing suicide |
Shown to 2nd year med students during geriatric
care block |
|
MS-4 Students view all to provide a self-
reflections writing assignments |
|
|
|
Bill Moyer's film series |
I use segments with patientÕs words about dying,
share perspective |
|
|
Brassed Off |
Life goals community |
British film, set in mining community |
|
Breathing Lessons |
Life of a person living in an iron lung(polio) |
Documentary - compassion issues with adjustment, chronic
care |
|
Cries and Whispers |
Untreated pain, suffering spiritual agony |
|
|
Dead Man Walking |
Reconciliation, healing, forgiveness at EOL |
|
|
Effroyables Jardins |
You cannot engage a person in meaningful
discussion, or even make them laugh, until you take care of their basic,
immediate needs |
French film; scene half-way through the film when
the clown is introduced |
|
The Doctor |
Life of a physician diagnosed with cancer |
Teaching communication skills, coping, empathy |
|
Role changes, change in perspective on time |
|
|
|
MS-4 Students view all to provide a self-
reflections writing assignments |
|
|
|
Communicating Empathy |
|
|
|
PatientÕs point of view, Dr. attitudes |
|
|
|
The Door in the
Floor |
Pathological grief tearing a family apart |
Show several images |
|
Driving Miss Daisy |
Last scene- feeding- another perspective |
|
|
ER Clips |
Various themes |
|
|
Field of Dreams |
Reconnecting/reestablishing relationships |
Final scene of father and son |
|
The Forgetting: A
Portrait of AlzheimerÕs (PBS) |
MS-4 Students view all to provide a self-
reflections writing assignments |
|
|
Forrest Gump |
Saying goodbye |
Final scene |
|
Fried Green Tomatoes |
|
|
|
Giant |
Living with a life-threatening illness |
|
|
Gilbert Grape |
Family systems/ dependency/dysfunction |
|
|
Go Now |
Diagnosis of and coming to terms with MS |
Some strong language. British film. Don't do a
spinal tap like shown! |
|
Goodbye Columbus |
Food as a social event – re: artificial
nutrition and hydration discussion |
|
|
Grumpy Old Men |
Life each day |
|
|
The Hours |
Attitudes towards death and dying, caregivers
feelings |
|
|
Ikiru |
EOL(5 stages), cross culture, spirituality |
Remarkable how resonant 1952 Japan was with current
issues |
|
A story about a Japanese Civil servant who develops
a terminal gastric cancer and finds a meaning of life after initial denial of
his disease |
By Akirakurosawa |
|
|
In the Bedroom |
Grief over loss of a child |
|
|
In the Gloaming |
Communication EOL |
|
|
Iris |
AlzheimerÕs/Empathy |
A wonderful insight into this disease for the
patient & caregiver |
|
AlzheimerÕs. Loss of a brilliant intellect,
caregiver difficulties |
Some strong language. Powerful portrayal of
struggles of elderly husband |
|
|
Life as a House |
Dealing with discussion about terminal disease with
children; love |
|
|
Meaning, accomplishment, reconciliation |
|
|
|
Lion King |
Speaking with children about death |
|
|
Traumatic death |
|
|
|
Lorenzo's Oil |
Devastating news, degenerative disease- hope and
desperation |
Measures family will go to for a cure |
|
Magnolia |
Conflicted relationships with dying parents |
|
|
Mortal Coil |
Compassion, understanding from patientÕs view |
Specific show about one patient who is comatose and
her thoughts |
|
Mostly Martha |
Personal growth/change resulting from death experience |
|
|
My Life as a Dog |
Swedish film about a boy who's mother is dying |
|
|
My Life without Me |
Legacy-building and dying poor |
Idea of 'risk' changing at EOL |
|
On Golden Pond |
Grief scene in shower |
Letting go |
|
One Flew Over the
CuckooÕs Nest |
"Establishment" control |
How nurses and doctors manipulate to be in
"control" and what recipients think and do to trust it |
|
One True Thing |
Caregiver role strain |
|
|
Ponette |
Four-year old French girl whose mother dies |
French film |
|
Regarding Henry |
Head injury-effect on a family |
|
|
Samuel Beckett's
"Footfalls" |
Tension between sick and caregiver |
|
|
Samuel Beckett's
"Rockaby" |
Solitary dying, death-wish of lonely/depressed |
|
|
The Sea Inside |
Withdrawal of support, autonomy |
Not available yet on video-still in theaters.
Spanish language with subtitles |
|
Seinfeld Segment
(TV) |
Advance care planning - segment with lawyer and
Elaine |
Humor |
|
Shadowland |
Growth at the end of life |
|
|
Love, pain, and grief |
Story of CS Lewis – how he rediscovers the
answer to his quote Òthe pain now is part of the happiness thenÓ |
|
|
Anticipating death |
|
|
|
Shawshank Redemption |
Defining and experiencing dignity; loss of
imaginative capacity; hope |
|
|
The Shootist |
Pain Meds |
End of life work |
|
Approaching death, pain |
I use the scenes where John Wayne's character is
discussing his approaching death with his doctor |
|
|
Snow White |
Speaking with children about death |
|
|
Stanley |
Medical uncertainty |
|
|
Steel Magnolias |
Loss, grief, religion and death |
|
|
Grief, parent losing a child |
|
|
|
Life Style choice, high tech, grief |
Terminal death |
|
|
Transitions, profound grief, cultural differences
between men and females ways of grieving |
|
|
|
Grief |
Mother's response to her daughter's death,
graveside scene |
|
|
The scene with Sally Fields at the cemetery expressing
anger over the death of the daughter |
I did use this entire film for critical care
interns. We had "movie" day one Friday every 6 weeks |
|
|
|
|
|
|
The Stepmother |
Honest communication, communication blockers |
Scene between mom and daughter towards the end of
movie. Scene begins with both parties trying to protect each other; makes to
an emotional/ honest discussion about dying. |
|
Dealing with discussion about terminal disease with
children; love |
|
|
|
Closure-saying good-bye, reconciliation |
|
|
|
Tampopo |
Role of medical team with dying patient meaning of
life for dying pt |
Japanese film |
|
Terms of Endearment |
Preparation for death, death at a young age,
inadequate care |
Use to show intern in hospital to what I am doing |
|
Pain Management |
Excellent scene on pain management in acute care
setting. Known as "the MSOY scene" |
|
|
Bad news, bad pain treatment |
Has been effective |
|
|
Waiting for shot (injection) |
Responding to pt/family pain |
|
|
Lack of pain control |
How pain "insensitivity" affects pt and
family. What pt family do to get pain relief |
|
|
Pain- mother/daughter relationship |
|
|
|
Thelma and Louise |
Self determination |
End scene |
|
Tom Jones |
Food as a social event – re: artificial
nutrition and hydration discussion |
|
|
Tuck Everlasting |
|
|
|
Tuesdays with Morrie |
Presence, personal growth, gradual decline |
There is so much, I select accordingly |
|
Turning Towards the
Mourning |
Grieving, stories of loss (powerful!) |
|
|
Waiting for God (BBC) |
Speaking with older pts, the question of euthanasia |
Episode on "Euthanasia" addressing how
physicians speak to older pts (or not) and the issue of euthanasia and respecting
a loved oneÕs wishes |
|
Who Speaks for
Robert? |
Discussing advance directives |
Great for showing importance of a advance
directives |
|
Wit |
Advocacy |
Staff RN telling the resident to leave PT alone as
her attempts to code her |
|
Cost of maintaining professional detachment |
The CPR scene where the nurse serves as patient
advocate against the doctor is very powerful |
|
|
Listening to Patient's goals; role modeling for
nurses |
|
|
|
English professor's personal experience with stage
IV metastatic ovarian cancer |
Shown to 2nd year med students during
pain/palliative care block |
|
|
Dying at the NIH |
Film is shown to family practice residents and many
of them identify with the NIH oncology fellow which leads to interesting
discussions |
|
|
Symptom management. Power of presence- "Runaway
Bunny" scene |
|
|
|
MS-4 Students view all to provide a self-
reflections writing assignments |
|
|
|
Research ethics, informed consent, communication |
|
|
|
Palliative care/hospice process |
Every section of the film can be used. We use it as
part of ELNEC training |
|
|
MD/patient relationship, DNR, and dying in hospital |
|
|
|
Truth telling/Hope |
Excellent for many aspects of EOL care teaching |
|
|
EOL, suffering |
|
|
|
Communication, suffering |
Moving scene where former teacher provides comfort
by reading a childrenÕs book, illustrates a way to alleviate suffering |
|
|
Dehumanization that can occur in medical system |
|
|
|
Communication, pain/ symptom management |
A wealth of topics- quite useful at many levels |
|
|
Breaking bad news |
MD telling patient her diagnosis: treatment plan,
symptom burden – vomiting |
|
|
Transitions, Communication, dying |
|
|
|
Witness |
Importance/ power of witness |
Samuel's witness of murder in train station BR-
child's witness to truth in adult world- it is scary; Harrison Ford's fist
fight in Lancaster- being witnessed- reciprocal nature of witness; Closing
scene outside barn- power of communal witness. |