From the AAHPM 2005 Annual Meeting: ÒChanging Lenses: Using Popular Film to Enhance Medical Education on Communication, Empathy and Self-ReflectionÓ

Daniel Johnson, MD, Life Quality Institute, Denver, Colorado

Film Title

Theme(s)

Other Comments

299 Days in the Life of Nora Lenihan

Hospice Care

 

A Family Undertaking

Normalizes dying

Family provide at home funerals

A Time to Kill

Empathy; loss of imaginative capacity

Final closing remarks of defense attorney

Bambi

Traumatic death

 

Scene after mother is shot

Healing after grief, surrounded by pals (except thumper!!)

Barbarian Invasions

Divided family coming together at end of life. Euthanasia

At the end of the film, death is hastened with I.V. heroin

Pt who learns he is dying, family and friends rally around him, he is able to die at home with their help

 

Beaches

Dying at home verses hospital, grief, childhood grief

Use to show peaceful death

Big Chill

Grief scene in shower

Letting go

Big Fish

"Death Narratives"

 

Bill MoyerÕs ÒHealing and the MindÓ

Bill Moyer's film series

Use example with Jon Kabat-Zinn group therapy to see how mindfulness can change a patient's life

Bill MoyerÕs ÒOn Our Own TermsÓ (PBS)

Clips on death/dying. ALS clip discussing suicide

Shown to 2nd year med students during geriatric care block

MS-4 Students view all to provide a self- reflections writing assignments

 

Bill Moyer's film series

I use segments with patientÕs words about dying, share perspective

Brassed Off

Life goals community

British film, set in mining community

Breathing Lessons

Life of a person living in an iron lung(polio)

Documentary - compassion issues with adjustment, chronic care

Cries and Whispers

Untreated pain, suffering spiritual agony

 

Dead Man Walking

Reconciliation, healing, forgiveness at EOL

 

Effroyables Jardins

You cannot engage a person in meaningful discussion, or even make them laugh, until you take care of their basic, immediate needs

French film; scene half-way through the film when the clown is introduced

The Doctor

Life of a physician diagnosed with cancer

Teaching communication skills, coping, empathy

Role changes, change in perspective on time

 

MS-4 Students view all to provide a self- reflections writing assignments

 

Communicating Empathy

 

PatientÕs point of view, Dr. attitudes

 

The Door in the Floor

Pathological grief tearing a family apart

Show several images

Driving Miss Daisy

Last scene- feeding- another perspective

 

ER Clips

Various themes

 

Field of Dreams

Reconnecting/reestablishing relationships

Final scene of father and son

The Forgetting: A Portrait of AlzheimerÕs (PBS)

MS-4 Students view all to provide a self- reflections writing assignments

 

Forrest Gump

Saying goodbye

Final scene

Fried Green Tomatoes

 

 

Giant

Living with a life-threatening illness

 

Gilbert Grape

Family systems/ dependency/dysfunction

 

Go Now

Diagnosis of and coming to terms with MS

Some strong language. British film. Don't do a spinal tap like shown!

Goodbye Columbus

Food as a social event – re: artificial nutrition and hydration discussion

 

Grumpy Old Men

Life each day

 

The Hours

Attitudes towards death and dying, caregivers feelings

 

Ikiru

EOL(5 stages), cross culture, spirituality

Remarkable how resonant 1952 Japan was with current issues

A story about a Japanese Civil servant who develops a terminal gastric cancer and finds a meaning of life after initial denial of his disease

By Akirakurosawa

In the Bedroom

Grief over loss of a child

 

In the Gloaming

Communication EOL

 

Iris

AlzheimerÕs/Empathy

A wonderful insight into this disease for the patient & caregiver

AlzheimerÕs. Loss of a brilliant intellect, caregiver difficulties

Some strong language. Powerful portrayal of struggles of elderly husband

Life as a House

Dealing with discussion about terminal disease with children; love

 

Meaning, accomplishment, reconciliation

 

Lion King

Speaking with children about death

 

Traumatic death

 

Lorenzo's Oil

Devastating news, degenerative disease- hope and desperation

Measures family will go to for a cure

Magnolia

Conflicted relationships with dying parents

 

Mortal Coil

Compassion, understanding from patientÕs view

Specific show about one patient who is comatose and her thoughts

Mostly Martha

Personal growth/change resulting from death experience

 

My Life as a Dog

Swedish film about a boy who's mother is dying

 

My Life without Me

Legacy-building and dying poor

Idea of 'risk' changing at EOL

On Golden Pond

Grief scene in shower

Letting go

One Flew Over the CuckooÕs Nest

"Establishment" control

How nurses and doctors manipulate to be in "control" and what recipients think and do to trust it

One True Thing

Caregiver role strain

 

Ponette

Four-year old French girl whose mother dies

French film

Regarding Henry

Head injury-effect on a family

 

Samuel Beckett's "Footfalls"

Tension between sick and caregiver

 

Samuel Beckett's "Rockaby"

Solitary dying, death-wish of lonely/depressed

 

The Sea Inside

Withdrawal of support, autonomy

Not available yet on video-still in theaters. Spanish language with subtitles

Seinfeld Segment (TV)

Advance care planning - segment with lawyer and Elaine

Humor

Shadowland

Growth at the end of life

 

Love, pain, and grief

Story of CS Lewis – how he rediscovers the answer to his quote Òthe pain now is part of the happiness thenÓ

Anticipating death

 

Shawshank Redemption

Defining and experiencing dignity; loss of imaginative capacity; hope

 

The Shootist

Pain Meds

End of life work

Approaching death, pain

I use the scenes where John Wayne's character is discussing his approaching death with his doctor

Snow White

Speaking with children about death

 

Stanley

Medical uncertainty

 

Steel Magnolias

Loss, grief, religion and death

 

Grief, parent losing a child

 

Life Style choice, high tech, grief

Terminal death

Transitions, profound grief, cultural differences between men and females ways of grieving

 

Grief

Mother's response to her daughter's death, graveside scene

The scene with Sally Fields at the cemetery expressing anger over the death of the daughter

I did use this entire film for critical care interns. We had "movie" day one Friday every 6 weeks

 

 

The Stepmother

Honest communication, communication blockers

Scene between mom and daughter towards the end of movie. Scene begins with both parties trying to protect each other; makes to an emotional/ honest discussion about dying.

Dealing with discussion about terminal disease with children; love

 

Closure-saying good-bye, reconciliation

 

Tampopo

Role of medical team with dying patient meaning of life for dying pt

Japanese film

Terms of Endearment

 

Preparation for death, death at a young age, inadequate care

Use to show intern in hospital to what I am doing

Pain Management

Excellent scene on pain management in acute care setting. Known as "the MSOY scene"

Bad news, bad pain treatment

Has been effective

Waiting for shot (injection)

Responding to pt/family pain

Lack of pain control

How pain "insensitivity" affects pt and family. What pt family do to get pain relief

Pain- mother/daughter relationship

 

Thelma and Louise

Self determination

End scene

Tom Jones

Food as a social event – re: artificial nutrition and hydration discussion

 

Tuck Everlasting

 

 

Tuesdays with Morrie

Presence, personal growth, gradual decline

There is so much, I select accordingly

Turning Towards the Mourning

Grieving, stories of loss (powerful!)

 

Waiting for God (BBC)

Speaking with older pts, the question of euthanasia

Episode on "Euthanasia" addressing how physicians speak to older pts (or not) and the issue of euthanasia and respecting a loved oneÕs wishes

Who Speaks for Robert?

Discussing advance directives

Great for showing importance of a advance directives

Wit

Advocacy

Staff RN telling the resident to leave PT alone as her attempts to code her

Cost of maintaining professional detachment

The CPR scene where the nurse serves as patient advocate against the doctor is very powerful

Listening to Patient's goals; role modeling for nurses

 

English professor's personal experience with stage IV metastatic ovarian cancer

Shown to 2nd year med students during pain/palliative care block

Dying at the NIH

Film is shown to family practice residents and many of them identify with the NIH oncology fellow which leads to interesting discussions

Symptom management. Power of presence- "Runaway Bunny" scene

 

MS-4 Students view all to provide a self- reflections writing assignments

 

Research ethics, informed consent, communication

 

Palliative care/hospice process

Every section of the film can be used. We use it as part of ELNEC training

MD/patient relationship, DNR, and dying in hospital

 

Truth telling/Hope

Excellent for many aspects of EOL care teaching

EOL, suffering

 

Communication, suffering

Moving scene where former teacher provides comfort by reading a childrenÕs book, illustrates a way to alleviate suffering

Dehumanization that can occur in medical system

 

Communication, pain/ symptom management

A wealth of topics- quite useful at many levels

Breaking bad news

MD telling patient her diagnosis: treatment plan, symptom burden – vomiting

Transitions, Communication, dying

 

Witness

Importance/ power of witness

Samuel's witness of murder in train station BR- child's witness to truth in adult world- it is scary; Harrison Ford's fist fight in Lancaster- being witnessed- reciprocal nature of witness; Closing scene outside barn- power of communal witness.